You are viewing [info]ery_90's journal

 
 
24 September 2009 @ 10:14 pm
Dorian Gray Review  
I must do that post! I'm sorry if I still don't post anything but this post is a MUST! (and tomorrow will be the same, no graphics post since I want to make a beautiful meme I saw from [info]nicolemissing , [info]faithforgiven and [info]misscla ).
Ok two days ago I saw Dorian Gray so I'm gonna post here my opinion about Ben-being-naked the movie. It might be spoiler, I don't know how much! But there is a reward for you under the cut! (I want the caps from the movieeee!!! I just need them!!! Ben had sex all the time! lol!)






First of all I want to thank London because Ben is everywhere! I like that! But I'm a little upset (and sat too) because the movie didn't have a premiere....So no real Ben in town. I was dreaming about that! And now my dream is broken ç____ç











Now let's talk about the movie! I apologize for my english, it'd be better if I wrote in italian, but I want to write in english!
I want to start saying that Dorian Gray is my favourite book ever. I love it, I love how Oscar Wilde wrote and I've read it like 3 o 4 times! And of course I love Ben. I was very happy when I heard Ben would have been Dorian. I know it can be a contradiction: I like the book and Ben, and we all know that he's not physically like Dorian. But, to be honest, I didn't mind, and after seing the movie I felt the same! Ben is a good actor and was a perfect Dorian.
Yes I said he was perfect, I don't know how to explain, but this role was just for him! I can't imagine another actor.
Maybe my opinion could have been influenced by the language. I didn't understand very well, and it was a shame! I did understand quite well Ben and some of the other characters, but Colin Firth was impossible to hear! And he's english, so he's supposed to have a perfect accents! I don't know if course it's only about me, my fault, but I found really difficult to understand him (and he's one of the most importante character in the movie!).

I'm trying to be objective
The movie is COMPLETELY DIFFERENT from the book, seriously there wasn't even one scene similiar to the novel. No one! Of course there were some but not in the same context. I would appreciate some similiar scene. But that's the problem of the movies based on novels.
And even the quotes (and I'm a little obsessed about DG's quotes), I only heard "The only way to get rid of temptation is to yield to it", but in this case, probably, I didn't understand the language, even if I know very well the english quotes.
I didn't like this change, well I knew that the movie was going to be too different, and in some parts of it I did liked it, but not this matter about the context and the quotes. Even Sibyl and Dorian's love story was quite different!But there's something more, and this is a huge spoiler, so don't look at these lines and go over. I'd advice you when you can start reading again.

  • Ok, I didn't like the love affairs (if we can call like this XD) between Dorian and Basil. That's not fair!! There wasn't sex (so you can guess what I'm talking about) but I hated that scene. That's the big mistake. In the book, Basil admires Dorian, he's the source of all his inspiration. Basil loves him, LOVES HIM, not that he wants his body, it's just love and ammiration, and he told Dorian, before being murdered. In the movie (in that scene) Basil seems like a whore! I didn't like it!

Ok you can start reading again.
Let's talk about sex! Yes I said sex! XD
In the book this word is never even mentioned, but in the movie...ehm emh, there're a lot of sex scenes, with Ben of course! I didn't like some of theme since he had sex with two older ladyies (not together!) so it was quite disgusting thinking about Ben with an old lady! But the other....Ben was so hot! And naked! But not too much! Just in the first scene with Sibyl.
So the sex-thing was good!! I think all of you will think the same! XD

Mmmm other things? The film could be quite good if you forget completely the book. I mean after the movie I didn't have the feeling "oh my god it was amazing!" I really needed to think about it hard, and now I honestly don't know If I liked it or not. Maybe half and half, I mean If I think about the differences between the movie and the book, ok maybe I don't like it. But if I only think about the movie itself, yes it was nice!

I'd like to write more, but I'm really tired right now.
And I'd like to discuss with you, so please tell me everything, even if you haven't seen the movie! And if you did I'd like to know your opinion!

And now a little picspam! I'm sorry it's too big!



Dorian Gray's Picspam


 
 
feel: sleepysleepy
Melody: Running up that hill // Placebo
 
 
( 12 shields — be my shield )
souvenir moi.: movie » dg » lhw/dg » adoration[info]explodeyy on September 24th, 2009 11:50 pm (UTC)
I don't think i'll be able to forget the book while watching it. I'll probably be bitching all throughout and pointing out a bunch of things. =P
I hate books-turned-movies, so i'm only watching the movie to see how they're going to go with it.
And because i've been a sucker for Basil/Dorian ever since i've started the book.

Mmmm, yummy picspam also. <3
Ery[info]ery_90 on September 25th, 2009 07:24 pm (UTC)
yeah I can understand you! I was trying to be objective...cause DG is really my favourite book. But yes I take your point, and you're right movies based on novel aren't so good, well not all!
But I didn't understand if you liked the idea of Basil/Dorian...forgive me but sometimes it's hard for me to understand english!
Reggie MoonLight: padrao[info]cantodoconto on September 25th, 2009 12:40 am (UTC)
*--*
Awww Thank You, hon! I loved your Bus´pix! and Your review. Great! I really want to watch this movie soon *-* I love Dorian Gray character and I think Ben was the perfect choice for play Dorian. I am anxiously waiting for release date in my country!
Ery: damonstefan[info]ery_90 on September 25th, 2009 07:25 pm (UTC)
Re: *--*
Yeah London was full of Ben's pics! I was so happy (I'm in Rome right now...my home!). And of course I agree with you, Ben was the perfect choice!
Susan[info]pooja_r on September 25th, 2009 02:22 am (UTC)
lucky ! i love bin bonz
Ery: harryomelette[info]ery_90 on September 25th, 2009 07:26 pm (UTC)
thank you! Well I'd like to meet the real Ben!
Anika: ronny[info]anikaboleyn on September 25th, 2009 11:12 am (UTC)
Yeah!
Thanks for sharing!!!
I want to see the movie so so bad!!!
Ery: littlebird[info]ery_90 on September 25th, 2009 07:27 pm (UTC)
Thank you!
I'm gonna see the movie in italian, when it will be released. Maybe I'll change my mind!
Laura: asoiaf ; {red viper}[info]haryan on December 11th, 2009 07:45 pm (UTC)
Ciao :D
spero non la prenderai male se ti commento in italiano, ma almeno non devo starci molto a pensare e posso dire chiaro e tondo quello che penso.
Sono perfettamente d'accordo con alcuni punti della tua recensione. Io adoro il libro, è probabilmente il mio preferito, e sono andata al cinema aspettandomi un film che seguisse la trama ed invece.. niente. La "relazione" tra Basil e Dorian era completamente sbagliata, c'era sesso ovunque quando nel libro.. Sybil guardava Dorian con un'adorazione da ragazza pura e casta ed invece qui è pure incinta XD
Non mi è piaciuta neanche l'invenzione della figlia di Henry, che non c'entrava nulla, nè il finale con il Dorian buono quando lui non si pente mai di ciò che ha fatto. Diciamo che ha un minimo tentennamento sul finale del libro, ma niente in confronto a ciò che invece succede alla fine del libro
Laura: ffxiii ; { cid }[info]haryan on December 11th, 2009 07:46 pm (UTC)
em.. intendevo niente in confronto a ciò che succede alla fine del film! hehe, sbaglio anche quando scrivo in italiano si direbbe :P
Ery: dorian2[info]ery_90 on December 12th, 2009 10:41 am (UTC)
no tranquilla non me la prendo! anzi mi fa piacere poterne discutere! Il film l'ho rivisto poche settimane fa in italiano, bhè perchè volevo capirlo un pò meglio. E infatti la lingua mi ha aiutato a farmi un'opinione diversa.
Sicuramente penso ancora quello che ho scritto la prima volta, e hai perfettamente ragione anche tu, però non so prima che iniziasse il film mi sono ripetuta "non è il libro, non ci pensare e goditi Ben" XD ed è quello che ho fatto alla fine!
Susan[info]kalibreeze on April 4th, 2010 04:14 pm (UTC)
i didn't like the dorian/basil thing either!
( 12 shields — be my shield )